Recipe: Mushroom Seitan Stroganoff

Pin It

Okay, it’s official: that groundhog LIED.

Now, I probably don’t have as much right to complain about the weather here in Northern California as the folks back East, but I’m going to anyway because this isn’t something we’re used to.  Evil, freezing temperatures, hurricane-style wind & rain, and possible snow in San Francisco.  IN SAN FRANCISCO!!!  This is definitely not the California-lovin’ weather I long for & miss ever-so-much.  But no matter how much I dream of warmer temperatures, I know they won’t be making an appearance for a long time because that cute little rodent who predicted an early spring is a compulsive liar (he did this last year, too).

More often than not, cold weather makes people crave comfort food, and I am no exception to that rule. Ergo, I’m happily wrapping myself in the warmth & comfort of dishes like beef stew, casseroles, and hearty soups while we deal with these frigid conditions.  But this time around, I wanted to try something a bit different that would be just as hearty and comforting as some of those other dishes.  It had been approximately forever & a day since I’d last had a good beef stroganoff with tender beef, mushrooms and plenty of savory sauce atop a bed of noodles, so that seemed like a good idea.  I had the noodles, I had the mushrooms, I had sauce fixings; but where was the beef?  Sadly, not in my kitchen.

Luckily, I still had a package of seitan hangin’ out in ye olde fridge, a definite score at just $3.49 at the Co-op the last time I went.  Though it’s not as inexpensive as tofu, seitan is a fabulous alternative to meat, and it does a much better job of mimicking a meaty texture than its more popular soy-based friend.  The few times I’ve cooked with it I’ve enjoyed it in place of chicken, so using it as “beef” was definitely a departure.

I ran into a few roadblocks when it came to making the sauce, since seitan doesn’t lend itself to browning as beef does.  Part of what makes some sauces so incredibly tasty is that fabulous deglazing process, when you use different liquids to break up the browned bits left behind by the meat to create a flavorful base.  But with the help of a few herbs & condiments, I was able to get a pretty decent flavored sauce that, while not authentic, was just perfect for my finished product.  Combined with perfectly cooked mushrooms and some thick noodles, this made for a fabulous entrée that I served with a crisp salad for an easy weeknight meal.

As I always do when I post a seitan recipe, I’m asking you to please proceed with caution if you have any sensitivity to wheat or wheat products.  I’m lucky not to have these sorts of issues and consider myself a proud omnivore, able and willing to enjoy a variety of different foods.  If you do have wheat allergies but still want to try this, no worries!  Simply omit the seitan and double the amount of mushrooms, and you’ll have a fantastic dinner.  Let’s check out the recipe!

Mushroom Seitan Stroganoff (makes 3-4 servings; total cost per serving: ~ $2.45)

1 8 oz. package seitan, cut into small chunks
4 oz. white mushrooms, sliced
2 garlic cloves, minced
1/4 c thinly sliced shallots or red onion
2 T olive oil
1/4 c Braggs Liquid Aminos or soy sauce
1/4 c white cooking wine
1/2 c nonfat plain yogurt or sour cream
1 t herbes de provence
1/2 t freshly ground black pepper
2 c cooked, thick-cut noodles (fettuccine, egg noodles, fussili, etc.)
2 T chopped scallions or chives (optional, for garnish)

Heat a large skillet over medium high heat and add the olive oil.  Add the garlic & shallots and cook for 1-2 minutes, or until fragrant and just lightly browned.  Reduce heat to medium, add the seitan and cook for about 3 minutes, followed by the mushrooms, herbes de provence and pepper.  Cook for another 2-3 minutes, or until the mushrooms begin to release some of their moisture and start to become tender.  Using a slotted spoon, remove the seitan & mushroom mixture (it’s okay to leave the shallots in the pan) and set aside in a bowl.

In the same pan, add the Braggs/soy sauce and wine and bring to a low simmer.  Quickly whisk in the yogurt (it helps if you’ve smoothed it out with a few whisks before adding it to the sauce; this will help avoid any curdling), and stir until completely incorporated.  Allow to simmer gently over medium low heat for about 1-2 minutes, stirring occasionally.  Return the seitan & mushroom mixture to the sauce and cook for another 3-4 minutes, so that the all the flavors are completely combined.

Spoon generous amounts of seitan, mushrooms and sauce over a bed of freshly cooked noodles, garnish with chopped chives & freshly ground black pepper, serve with a nice salad, and enjoy!

written by

singer. writer. artist. champagne taste, 2 buck chuck budget. good cook. kooky. chocoholic. patron saint of cats. talker. listener. thinker. sometimes to a fault.

8 Responses to "Recipe: Mushroom Seitan Stroganoff"

  1. Lucy @ Lucyeats says:

    I've just stumbled on your site and, may I say, what a great idea! I know way too many poor students with picky palates and not enough money to support their tastes. Good job on teaching everyone that eating cheap does not mean surviving on cans of spaghetti each week!

  2. Tiffany says:

    Great idea! I haven't had stroganoff since I gave up meat 16 years ago!!!! :D

  3. Anonymous says:

    Just made it. VERY hearty. VERY delicious. I'm a meat-eater looking for vegetarian alternatives and this was quite filling. Used whole-wheat pasta. Didn't have Braggs so used hi-octane soy sauce. Also used Westsoy Seitan. Was good but kinda salty. Is there a brand of seitan that is less salty?

    ~ Ken

  4. Anonymous says:

    This sounds so tasty and I can't wait to try it! This might be a stupid (read: non-cook) question, but were the herbs de Provence fresh or dried?

  5. Betty Banning says:

    Looks yummy! I'll try it.

  6. Recipe: Penne with Spicy Beef & Mushroom Sauce | Poor Girl Eats Well — How to eat ridiculously well on a minuscule budget. says:

    [...] I’m an umami fanatic, I decided to amp up the hearty, meaty quality of my sauce with some mushrooms.  They not only enhance the flavor & texture, they also help stretch out the sauce without [...]

  7. Billie says:

    I made this recipe and was amazed!! It was so delicious!

  8. Kate says:

    my boyfriend and i make this CONSTANTLY. thank you for turning him on to seitan! :)


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>